Scrum Alternatives: All You Need to Know

Are you feeling constrained by the rigidity of Scrum? Wondering if there’s a better way to manage your projects? Look no further! Scrum Framework’s iterative approach, emphasis on collaboration, and adaptability have made it a popular choice for teams aiming for efficiency and flexibility in product development. However, Scrum isn't the only game in town and exploring Scrum Alternatives from Kanban to Lean can help you break free from Scrum’s limitations.  

In this blog, we'll explore methodologies like Kanban, Kanban with Scrumban practices, Lean, and Crystal, each catering to different project requirements and team dynamics.  By understanding the core principles and benefits of each approach, you'll be empowered to choose the ideal framework to streamline your workflow, boost team productivity, and achieve project goals with greater agility. So, let us discover the exciting world of Scrum Alternatives – the key to unlocking a more flexible and successful development journey! 

Table of Contents 

1) Scrum Alternatives 

   a) Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe)  

   b) Large-Scale Scrum (LeSS) 

   c) XP (Extreme Programming) 

   d) Crystal 

   e) Nexus 

   f) Kanban 

2) Conclusion 

Scrum Alternatives 

Scrum Alternatives offer diverse approaches to Agile Methodologies, catering to various organisational needs and project complexities. Each alternative presents unique features and benefits, empowering organisations to choose the approach that best suits their objectives. So, let’s have a look at top Scrum Alternatives and find out: 

1) Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe) 

The Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe) is designed to address the challenges of scaling from the team level to program levels and portfolio organisations. It takes a holistic view and extends the boundaries to management and stakeholders, not just the development team. Therefore, it extends the Agile principles to the entire enterprise through increased alignment, enhanced collaboration, and better delivery across large numbers of Agile teams and projects. 

SAFe also works on Lean-Agile leadership where leaders give support to Agile teams and create a culture of improvement and innovation. SAFe ensures alignment and synchronisation across varied teams with guidance on different levels of organisational roles, ceremonies, and artefacts as they work effectively towards common goals. 

Key features of SAFe include: 

1) Program Increment (PI) planning: SAFe introduces the concept of PI Planning, a cadence-based, timeboxed event where all Agile Release Trains (ARTs) plan and commit to a set of objectives for the upcoming Program Increment. PI Planning ensures alignment, synchronisation, and visibility across multiple teams. 

2) Release train: Teams in SAFe work together in synchronised iterations, known as Release Trains, ensuring alignment and coordination across the organisation. 

3) Lean-Agile leadership: SAFe emphasises the role of leadership in driving organisational change and fostering an environment conducive to agility. Lean-Agile Leaders support and empower teams, remove impediments, and promote a culture of continuous improvement.
 

2) Large-scale Scrum (LeSS) 

Large-scale Scrum or LeSS is an adaptation of Scrum to tackle projects involving more than one team. Scrumban retains all the basic order of Scrum and adds rules to navigate complex environments and integrate teams. LeSs calls for simplifications, openness and focus on the client’s side of the organisation. 

In this regard, LeSS operates under the notion of a whole team, in which all product development team members are involved in the process. In contrast to traditional large-scale frameworks that bring in multiple backlogs, LeSS ensures that there is only one product backlog for the whole product for maximal clarity and focus on goals. It also allows several teams that work simultaneously on the same product to merge into one team with no difference. 

Key features of LeSS include: 

a) Single product backlog: Unlike traditional scaled frameworks that introduce multiple backlogs, LeSS maintains a single Product Backlog for the entire product, ensuring clarity and focus. This promotes clarity, alignment, and a shared understanding of priorities across all teams. 

b) Whole-team approach: LeSS encourages the whole team to take collective ownership of product development rather than dividing responsibilities based on specialised roles. This fosters collaboration, knowledge sharing, and a focus on delivering value as a unified team. 

c) Lean thinking: LeSS incorporates principles of lean thinking, such as minimising waste, optimising flow, and amplifying learning. By applying lean principles to product development, teams can streamline their processes, reduce cycle times, and deliver value more efficiently. 

Improve your organisational efficiency through our Scrum For Teams Course!   

3) Extreme Programming (XP) 

Extreme Programming, or XP, is the Agile process model of Scrum, which is centred on engineering practices and teamwork. The customer is placed at the centre of the process, satisfaction, feedback, and even improvement. XP covers areas that are not addressed directly by Scrum practices and integrates these areas into the software development process. XP emerged in the late 1990s and stands on several key principles and practices to improve the quality of the software and ensure that the work is adjusted to customers’ needs. 

Another important principle of XP is commitment to customer satisfaction. Thus, the company focuses on satisfying the needs expressed by the customers following the communication with them and receiving their feedback. Such a customer-oriented approach leaves no doubt that the outcome – the delivered software – corresponds to the customer’s vision. 

Key features of XP include: 

a) Pair Programming: Here, two Programmers work simultaneously at the same workstation. One is the Code Writer, and the other is the reviewer. The overall outcome is cooperation, knowledge sharing, and instant feedback that enhances code quality, clarity, and the productivity of the programmers. 

b) Test-Driven Development (TDD): This approach involves writing tests before writing the code that defines the functionality. It's the process of developing a failing test, writing a minimal amount of code to pass the test, and then refactoring the implemented code. TDD ensures fast feedback, high code quality, and maintainability by identifying bugs early and encouraging better design. 

c) Continuous Integration (CI): Developers frequently commit their code changes into shared repositories, triggering automated builds and tests. CI helps detect integration problems early and provides prompt feedback, keeping the software in a nearly working state, reducing conflicts, and improving code quality and reliability. 

4) Crystal 

Crystal is a subset of Agile methodologies created by Alistair Cockburn. It acknowledges that every project is unique and tries to adapt to the specific project characteristics in its own way. Crystal methodologies emphasise communication, clarity, and self-reflection. 

Another characteristic attribute of Crystal would be that this framework is centred on communication. Crystal methodologies highlight the need for regular and open communication with the team members and customers as well as other stakeholders. Holding regular meetings and encouraging the exchange of information promote requirements awareness, recognition of issues and risks, decision-making. 

One of them is named the principle of simplicity, which indicates that ‘the message should be simple, clear and not overloaded by excessive components. While there is a possible drawback in suggesting a set of rigid new patterns, Crystal focuses on stating that the teams should use lightweight forms of communication that are convenient for the team. 

It brings the heaviest work towards more planning into the elaboration phase, which makes this approach pragmatic and keeps the teams on track while avoiding overheads. Therefore, Crystal can be used with Scrum or can be implemented as a solution that is more suitable for a team that does not want to undertake a strict Scrum framework. 

Key features of Crystal include: 

a) Team size: Crystal adjusts the size of a team based on project complexity. Smaller teams, usually consisting of 5 to 9 members, are used for simpler projects to improve agility and communication. For complex projects, larger teams with diverse skills are deployed to ensure proper performance and effective resource alignment. 

b) Frequent delivery: Crystal methodologies emphasise the regular delivery of working software throughout the project. This approach allows for incremental value delivery and early stakeholder feedback, promoting transparency, trust, and reducing rework by validating assumptions continuously and aligning with customer needs. 

c) Reflective improvement: Regular reflection on team processes and outcomes helps identify areas for improvement. Through retrospectives, teams can inspect and adapt their practices, fostering a learning environment. This continuous improvement leads to higher-quality products that better meet customer needs. 

Improve your managerial skills with our Managing Agile Projects With Scrum Course!   

5) Nexus 

Nexus is a framework for scaling Scrum developed by Ken Schwaber, co-creator of Scrum. It provides guidelines and practices for organisations that require multiple Scrum teams to work together on a single product. Nexus builds on Scrum principles and enhances them for scaled environments. 

Key features of Nexus include: 

a) Nexus integration team: Nexus introduces the role of the Nexus Integration Team, responsible for ensuring alignment and integration across multiple Scrum teams. By coordinating dependencies, resolving conflicts, and removing impediments, the Nexus Integration Team helps to streamline the development process and ensure that all teams are working towards common goals. 

b) Nexus events: Nexus defines additional events, such as Nexus Sprint Planning and Nexus Sprint Review, to facilitate coordination and collaboration among teams. For example, Nexus Sprint Planning brings together representatives from each team to plan and coordinate their work for the upcoming Sprint. Similarly, Nexus Sprint Review provides a forum for teams to showcase their work and gather feedback from stakeholders. 

c) Nexus artifact: Nexus introduces the Nexus Sprint Backlog, which aggregates the individual Sprint Backlogs of multiple Scrum teams, providing visibility and transparency at scale. 

6) Kanban 

Kanban is a visual management method used to optimise workflow, limit work in progress, and maximise efficiency. While not a direct alternative to Scrum, Kanban can complement Scrum or serve as an alternative for teams that prefer a more flexible approach. 

Kanban also promotes transparency and collaboration. By making the workflow visible to all team members, stakeholders, and customers, Kanban fosters communication and alignment. Everyone can see the status of tasks, identify blockers, and collaborate to resolve issues, leading to improved coordination and delivery. 

Key features of Kanban include: 

a) Visual board: Kanban utilises a visual board to represent the workflow, with columns representing different stages of work and cards representing individual tasks. 

b) Work in Progress (WIP) limits: Kanban imposes limits on the number of tasks allowed in each stage of the workflow, preventing overburdening and encouraging focus. 

c) Continuous improvement: Kanban promotes continuous improvement through regular review and adaptation of the workflow, identifying bottlenecks and optimising processes. 

Conclusion 

While Scrum has proven to be effective for many teams, it's essential to recognize that it may not be the best fit for every organization or project. By exploring these Scrum Alternatives and understanding how they compare to the Scrum workflow, you can choose the approach that best aligns with your team's goals and objectives. Remember, the key is not to adhere rigidly to a single methodology but to continuously adapt and evolve based on feedback and experience.

Improve your Scrum skills through our Scrum Developer Training.