Azure AD vs Active Directory: Key Differences

Picture this: your company is growing at an unprecedented rate, and you need a reliable system to manage user identities and access. Should you choose the tried-and-true on-premises Active Directory, or the innovative, cloud-based Azure AD? This choice can profoundly affect your Information Technology (IT) infrastructure and operational efficiency. In this blog, we will talk about the key differences between Azure AD vs Active Directory to help you make the best decision.

By examining the distinctions between Azure AD vs Active Directory, we aim to help you with this critical decision, ensuring your organisation's identity and access management needs are effectively met. Let's dive in and discover which solution aligns best with your requirements.

Table of Contents

1) What Is Azure AD?  

2) What is Microsoft Active Directory?  

3) Azure AD vs Active Directory: Similarities  

4) Azure AD vs Active Directory: Differences  

5) Advantages of Azure AD

6) Advantages of Azure Active Directory

7) Considerations for Choosing Between Azure AD and Active Directory  

8) What is the Purpose of Azure AD?

9) What are the Three Types of Azure AD Users?

10) Conclusion 

What is Azure AD? 

As a cloud-based directory, Azure Active Directory (Azure AD) identities and accesses management service provided by Microsoft. It offers a centralised directory for managing user identities, authentication, and authorisation within the Azure cloud environment, as well as other connected services and applications. Azure AD extends the capabilities of on-premises Active Directory into the Azure cloud.

Azure AD provides multiple features to secure cloud-based applications, guarantee compliance, and streamline Information Technology (IT) processes, including:

a) Cloud-based Identity Management: Centralises user identities and authentication mechanisms.

b) Single Sign-On (SSO) and Multi-factor Authentication (MFA): Supports SSO and MFA, requiring users to provide multiple forms of verification before accessing resources.

c) Application Integration: Seamlessly integrates with various Microsoft services and supports multiple authentication protocols and standards, ensuring compatibility with a wide array of applications.

d) B2B and B2C Identity Scenarios: Facilitates secure collaboration with external partners and permits businesses to manage identities and authentication for their customers.  

 

 

 

What is Active Directory? 

Active Directory is an on-premises directory service that enables organisations to establish a local Windows Server domain for managing large-scale networks. Essentially, AD functions as a database that stores information about all users, groups, devices, and policies within a Windows environment. 

Active Directory domains are centrally managed by Domain Controllers (DCs), which store this database, authenticate users, and apply group policy settings. To prevent outages, multiple domain controllers replicating the same information are used concurrently. 

Additionally, within an Active Directory domain, users and computers can be organised into different organisational units, reflecting the hierarchical structure of DCs and regular machines.

Azure AD vs. Active Directory: Similarities 

Azure Active Directory (Azure AD) and the Active Directory (AD) both serve as Microsoft's identity and access management solutions. Still, they share several key features that are vital for organisations operating hybrid environments. Here are some of them:

a) Integration with With Microsoft Products: 

Both Azure AD and Active Directory are deeply integrated with the Microsoft surroundings, which incorporates Office 365, Windows Server, and enterprise applications including SharePoint and Exchange. This integration helps streamline the management of security regulations and user credentials across diverse Microsoft offerings.

b) Identity and Access Management:

At their core, both Azure AD and AD handle identity and access management (IAM), managing user identities, authenticating logins, and authorising access to network resources. This capability is crucial for enhancing security and operational efficiency within an organisation. 

c) Support for Single Sign-On (SSO):

Both platforms support Single Sign-On (SSO), although they implement it differently. Active Directory provides SSO within on-premises networks, while Azure AD extends this feature to cloud services, enabling users to access both Microsoft and third-party SaaS applications with a single set of credentials. 

d) Directory Services:

Both use directory services to store and manage information about network resources. Active Directory uses a hierarchical structure suitable for detailed management, whereas Azure AD uses a simpler, flat structure that scales efficiently in cloud environments. 

e) Security Features:

Azure AD and Active Directory both offer strong security features, including multi-factor authentication (MFA) and extensive auditing and logging capabilities. These features help monitor access and changes within the network, enhancing security governance and compliance. 

f) Scalability and Reliability:

Both systems are designed to be scalable and reliable—AD scales within an on-premises setup and Azure AD scales in the cloud. Azure AD's cloud-based model, managed by Microsoft, allows for automatic scaling to meet global demands. 

If you're curious about the Microsoft Azure SQL Service, sign up for our Administering Microsoft Azure SQL Solutions DP300 Course now! 

Azure AD vs. Active Directory: Differences 

Now that we have gone through the similarities, let's have a look at the differences between the two. Here are some of the significant differences between Active Directory and Azure Ad:

1) Deployment 

Active Directory: 

Active Directory is typically deployed on-premises within an organisation's IT infrastructure. It requires server hardware, which can be a single server for small environments or multiple servers for fault tolerance and load balancing in larger organisations. 

Installation and maintenance of AD can be complex and require the ongoing management of hardware and software updates. 

Azure AD: 

Azure AD is a cloud-based service, meaning it is hosted on Microsoft's cloud infrastructure and accessed via the internet. This model removes the need for organisations to invest in and maintain their own server hardware. 

Azure AD offers easy scalability as it can be expanded seamlessly with additional resources in the cloud based on the organisation’s needs. 

2) Authentication Methods 

Active Directory: 

AD relies on traditional domain join and Kerberos/NTLM for authentication within on-premises networks. This setup is well-suited for internal network environments where all devices are connected to the corporate network. 

Azure AD: 

Azure AD uses modern authentication protocols such as OAuth 2.0, OpenID Connect, and SAML 2.0. These protocols provide secure identity management and access controls for applications that are accessible over the internet, making it ideal for modern enterprise by utilising a combination of cloud and on-premises resources. 

Sign up for our Microsoft Azure Fundamentals AZ900 Course to imbibe insights on the fundamental cloud concept!     

Directory Structure 

Active Directory: 

AD is known for its hierarchical structure, which can include the forest, domains, organisational units, and individual objects. This structure is ideal for large organisations with complex organisational charts and can support detailed delegation of administration rights. 

Group Policy Objects (GPOs) are used extensively in AD to enforce security settings and other configurations across the network. 

Azure AD: 

Azure AD does not utilise a hierarchical structure like AD. Instead, it manages identities and accesses using a flat structure that includes users and groups. While this can be less complex to manage, it may provide a different level of granular control over permissions and policies than AD. 

Azure AD includes features like conditional access policies, which provide dynamic access control based on user, location, device health, and risk level. 

Management Tools 

Active Directory: 

AD can be managed through various Microsoft Management Consoles like Active Directory Users and Computers (ADUC), Active Directory Administrative Center, and via PowerShell scripts. 

AD requires manual or semi-automated management processes, which can be resource-intensive. 

Azure AD: 

Azure AD is managed through the Azure portal, which provides a web-based interface for administrative tasks. It can also be managed via Azure AD PowerShell and the Microsoft Graph API for programmatic access. 

Azure AD management can be automated and integrated with other Azure services, providing a more streamlined administration experience than traditional AD.

Advantages of Azure AD

A cloud-based service like Azure AD offers several advantages over on-premises infrastructure, primarily due to its convenience and ease of use. Here are some of the benefits of Azure AD:

a) No Upfront Costs: There is no need to set up domain controllers or invest in your own hardware. All you require to get started is a subscription.

b) Easily Scalable: With access to Microsoft's extensive cloud infrastructure, you can effortlessly add more users or rent additional storage.

c) Maintained for you: Your tenant is always kept up to date, automatically receiving security patches and new features without any extra effort.

d) Available From Anywhere: Cloud apps and identities enable your users to sign in from any location, provided they adhere to your conditional access policies.

Advantages of Active Directory

While cloud services are often hailed as the future, it's important to recognise that on-premises infrastructure has its own strengths and use cases. Here are some advantages of Active Directory:

a) Potentially Cheaper in the Long run: Although cloud services offer convenience, this comes at a premium. Over time, investing in your own infrastructure can be more cost-effective than renting it. 

b) Greater Control: Operating a local Active Directory provides more granular control, which can be particularly relevant for supporting legacy applications or complex, multi-domain environments.

c) Keep Sensitive Data in-house: Certain information may be better kept or processed on-premises for security or compliance reasons.

d) Manage Your own Risk: Automatic updates do not guarantee complete security, as evidenced by recent breaches like that of Exchange Online. In some scenarios, you may prefer to manage this risk yourself rather than relying on a cloud provider.

Considerations for Choosing Between Azure AD and Active Directory 

When deciding between Azure AD and Active Directory, several factors should be taken into account:

a) Cost: Evaluate the long-term costs associated with both options. While Azure AD may have higher recurring costs, it eliminates the need for upfront investments in hardware and maintenance. Conversely, Active Directory might be more cost-effective over time, depending on your organisation's size and infrastructure needs.

b) Control and Customisation: Consider the level of control and customisation required. Active Directory offers more granular control, which can be crucial for managing complex environments and legacy applications. Azure AD, while highly functional, may not provide the same level of customisation.

c) Scalability: Assess your scalability needs. Azure AD excels in scalability, allowing you to easily add users and resources as your organisation grows. Active Directory, while scalable, may require additional hardware and maintenance efforts.

d) Security and Compliance: Determine your security and compliance requirements. Azure AD benefits from Microsoft's robust security infrastructure and automatic updates, ensuring compliance with the latest standards. However, if keeping sensitive data in-house is a priority, Active Directory might be the better choice.

e) Accessibility: Consider the accessibility needs of your users. Azure AD enables remote access from anywhere, which is ideal for organisations with a distributed workforce. Active Directory, on the other hand, is more suited for environments where users primarily operate within a local network.

f) Integration: Evaluate the integration capabilities with your existing systems and applications. Azure AD offers seamless integration with various Microsoft services and supports multiple authentication protocols. Active Directory is well-suited for environments heavily reliant on Windows-based systems.

What is the Purpose of Azure AD?

Azure Active Directory (Azure AD) is a cloud-based identity and access management service. Its purpose is to secure access to resources like applications, services, and devices while enabling seamless collaboration and user authentication across organisations.

What are the Three Types of Azure AD Users?

The three types of Azure AD users are:

1) Cloud Users – Created directly in Azure AD

2) Guest Users – External users invited for collaboration

3) Hybrid Users – Synced from on-premises Active Directory

Master the basics of Azure with our Microsoft Azure Fundamentals PDF. Download now and start your certification prep!

Conclusion 

In summary, the decision between Azure AD vs Active Directory depends on your organisation's unique requirements and goals. By making an informed decision, you can develop a robust identity and access management strategy that enhances your organisation's growth and security. Additionally, understanding the difference between PowerShell and CMD can help you choose the right command-line interface for your specific administrative needs.

Ready to kick start your career in Microsoft Azure? Register for our  Microsoft Azure Training now!