Portfolio Management vs Project Management

In most cases, there is always debate on which process best suits the attainment of organisational goals: Portfolio Management or Project Management. Although they seem related to one another these two disciplines are different but could be seen as a match to complement the other in the overall strategic scheme. 

While project management can be seen as the skilled architect who is working on a single project to complete a single great piece, portfolio management is the planner who oversees the city and makes sure all the buildings fit into the greater plan. 

Portfolio Management vs Project Management is essential for business for several reasons because the two functions are interdependent. Portfolio management is all about managing a suite of projects and making sure they support the organisation’s goals and objectives; project management, on the other hand, focuses on the details of getting the projects done right. 

Table of Contents 

1) Understanding Portfolio Management  

2) Understanding Project Management  

3) What is Project Portfolio Management? 

4) Key Differences Between Portfolio Management and Project Management  

5) Synergy Between Portfolio Management and Project Management  

6) Conclusion  

Understanding Portfolio Management   

Portfolio Management is the effective and efficient management of projects, programs and other endeavors that a business may undertake. That is concerned with the management of a collection of assets to accomplish the aims of an organisation and create the most value. Portfolio Managers are responsible for a number of activities and initiatives, and they must be in accordance with organisational goals. 
They evaluate the degree of accomplishment of projects, distribute funds, control disturbances and ascertain which projects should be embarked on, according to the possible yields and the level of compatibility.
 

Understanding Project Management   

Project Management focuses on the management and completion of certain projects. This comprises of project designing, coordinating activities, directing and supervising the whole process of performing a project in accordance with reasonable and measurable goals regarding cost, time, and quality standards. 

Project Managers take responsibility for coordinating interdisciplinary teams, determining project objectives and timelines, identifying and controlling threats and evaluating performances to ensure that projects are successfully accomplished.

What is Project Portfolio Management? 

As a strategic process of selecting, prioritising and controlling projects and programs in Project Portfolio Management, it is a tool which is aimed at the achievement of organisational goals and objectives. It is an integrated solution, which allows you to manage resources, costs, risks and benefits of the Project Portfolio at their best. 

It also includes assessing the value of Performance and Portfolio and making changes whenever there is a change of needs and expectations by the stakeholders in PPM. PPM is generally employed by the Portfolio Managers or a Project Management Offices (PMO) with the support of PPM tools.

Key Differences Between Portfolio Management and Project Management   

The major differences between Portfolio Management and Project Management are as follows:

1) Focus and Scope 

Portfolio Management focuses on the overall collection of projects and their alignment with strategic objectives. It considers the interdependencies, resource allocation, and overall portfolio performance. In contrast, Project Management focuses on individual projects. Itensures that projects are executed efficiently, meet their specific objectives, and deliver the desired outcomes. 

2) Timeframe 

Portfolio Management typically operates on a longer timeframe, often spanning several years or even decades. It involves continuous portfolio evaluation, adjustment, and optimisation based on changing business needs. Project Management, however, operates within a defined timeframe, consisting of distinct project phases from initiation to completion. 

3) Objectives 

The objectives of Portfolio Management revolve around maximising the value and strategic alignment of the entire portfolio. It aims to balance risks and returns, optimise resource allocation, and achieve long-term business goals. Project Management, on the other hand, focuses on delivering specific outcomes within predetermined constraints, such as meeting project deadlines, staying within budget, and delivering the expected scope. 

4) Stakeholders 

Portfolio Management deals with a broader range of stakeholders, including executive management, investors, and other strategic decision-makers. It involves aligning the portfolio with organisational goals and addressing the needs and expectations of various stakeholders. In contrast, Project Management primarily focuses on the stakeholders directly involved in a particular project, such as project team members, sponsors, and end-users. 

5) Risk Management 

Portfolio Management involves managing risks at a higher level. It aims to assess and mitigates risks across the entire portfolio, considering potential impacts on strategic objectives and overall performance. On the other hand, Project Management focuses on identifying and managing risks specific to individual projects. The aim is to ensure that projects are completed successfully and within defined parameters. 

6) Resource Allocation 

Portfolio Management involves strategic resource allocation across multiple projects and initiatives. It aims to optimise the utilisation of resources based on the portfolio's priorities, strategic goals, and risk appetite. In comparison, Project Management focuses on allocating resources within the constraints of a specific project to ensure efficient execution and timely delivery. 

7) Performance Measurement 

Portfolio Management evaluates the performance of the entire portfolio, considering financial metrics, strategic objectives, and other key performance indicators. It assesses the contribution of individual projects to the overall portfolio performance. Project Management focuses on measuring the performance of individual projects based on predefined success criteria, such as project deliverables, budget adherence, and stakeholder satisfaction. 

8) Decision-making 

Decision-making is a crucial aspect of both Portfolio Management and Project Management. However, the scope of decision-making differs in each case.

Portfolio Managers make strategic decisions that affect the entire portfolio of projects, while Project Managers make practical decisions that affect individual projects.

Portfolio Managers select and prioritise the projects that align with the organisation’s vision and mission. On the other hand, Project Managers plan and execute the project activities based on the project scope, schedule, budget, and resources.

While Portfolio Managers balance various trade-offs and consider factors such as strategic fit, resource requirements, risk profiles, and expected returns, Project Managers solve problems and deal with uncertainties that arise during the project lifecycle.

Master the art of managing projects and achieve success with our comprehensive range of Project Management Courses!

How Does a Portfolio Manager Differ from a Project Manager

As different goals and strategies share the main focus of portfolio management and project management, the tasks of the portfolio manager vs project manager are different as well.

Portfolio Manager

Main responsibility of a portfolio manager is to ensure that the right projects are allocated to his or her particular portfolio. This entails taking time to look at each project discreetly and assess if the project has a relevance to the business in the long-term, as well as whether the project will yield a strategic value. Common tasks a portfolio manager may oversee include:

a) Managing financial resources

b) Moreover, deciding on the possible outcomes of any action to be taken

c) Prioritising projects

d) It is the disciplining of tasks in that they have to be done at the required time

e) Tracking real-time analytics

f) Employing the simultaneous approach to help on the overall needs of the company

Project Manager

A project manager looks at the main factors of individual objectives that need to be met to contribute to a broader plan. Showing good time management skills and in addition, coming up with ideas as to how any critical issues might be prevented are some of the most important functions of project managers. Other responsibilities include:

a) Outlining budget requirements

b) The process of assigning values and setting milestones to certain activities

c) Identifying objectives and potential results of project

d) Describing project progress

e) Applying measures to achieve target on project goals

Synergy between Portfolio Management and Project Management   

The synergy between Portfolio Management and Project Management is crucial for achieving organisational goals: 

a) Strategic Alignment: Portfolio Management defines the direction for selecting, categorising, and funding the Project s to meet the organisational objectives. Project Management makes sure the accomplishment of such projects and supports organisational strategic direction.

b) Resource Optimisation: Portfolio Management aims at the most effective and efficient use of resources against the background of aims and objectives of the Portfolio. Project Management utilises resources within projects effectively. 

c) Communication and Collaboration: There is a need to develop good communication and interaction now among everyone that is involved in the project. Portfolio Management translates strategic direction, priorities and resource allocations into goals, plans, and decisions to be made by Project Managers. 

d) Performance Measurement: Portfolio Management makes an assessment of the extent to which the overall portfolio has met its performance targets either in financial or management parameters. Measuring value for Project Management involves evaluating individual project performance with regard to deliverables, cost control and satisfaction among stakeholders.  

e) Continuous Improvement: Teamwork helps to ensure the work is improving steadily all the time. Several beneficiaries are derived from improved lessons learned practice in the aspects of project selection, resource management and risk management which improves project efficiency and effectiveness.

This makes it easier for both Portfolio and Project Management to provide support to the accomplishment of organisational goals in the best way possible.

Learn how to implement Portfolio Management methodologies! Register for our Management of Portfolios (MoP®) Foundation & Practitioner Course now!   

Conclusion 

Lastly, Portfolio Management aims at balancing the overall project portfolio against the corporate objectives, goals and mandate while Project Management is the day to day undertaking of delivering a specific project. Realising these differences is important for organisations to optimally control and apply project and portfolio management for any sustainable business.

Achieve excellence in the field of Portfolio Management with our MoP® Management of Portfolios Course!